18 December 2019

Festive ads: the crackers and turkeys of 2019

Haven’t managed to catch up with all the big retail Christmas adverts yet?

They’re a brilliant way of engaging customers each year and conveying messages with high creativity. Lucy from the Synergy team has given her thoughts on which ads have been spreading that Christmas cheer this year and the ones that might leave you shivering in the cold…

 

Tesco

Tesco have gone with a feel-good family factor with their ‘Delivering Christmas’ campaign. The Back to the Future reference ties everything together as a delivery driver travels through time dropping off people’s festive food. This one appeals to everyone, with references spanning several decades. 

Lucy’s verdict:

Entertainment value – 8/10

Marketing success score – 5/10

 

John Lewis Waitrose collaboration

Another strong attempt from John Lewis and Waitrose, with a narrative that brings both brands together to highlight their partnership. 

A focus on brilliant originality and it appeals to the younger audience too – no doubt sales of Edgar the dragon are booming right now!

Lucy’s verdict:

Entertainment value – 9/10

Marketing success score – 5/10

 

Sainsbury’s

Cinematic storytelling from Sainsbury’s this year with the story of Nicholas the Sweep, a young chimney sweep who goes on to become Father Christmas.

Great production and entertainment in this one, but perhaps slightly lacking in a strong brand call-to-action, with little reference to why you should shop at Sainsbury’s this festive season. 

Entertainment value – 9/10

Market success – 4/10

 

Asda

A nice try from Asda this year, but not much by way of product or brand reference. They’ve gone with a sweet narrative but the delivery falls a little short this time. 

They seem to be trying quite hard to do a lot of different things but maybe left the audience a bit lost. 

Lucy’s verdict: 

Entertainment value – 6/10

Marketing success – 3/10

 

Aldi

Immediately recognisable, Aldi has brought back everyone’s favourite character Kevin the Carrot for another Christmas ad. Not taking themselves too seriously works well and The Greatest Showman reference will inevitably add to the family appeal.

Lucy’s verdict: 

Entertainment value – 8/10

Marketing success – 7/10

 

Lidl

A no-frills approach from Lidl this year, with a big product and brand message. A little obvious at times but a family feel leaves us with a bit of Christmas spirit and a need to get to Lidl quickly before they sell out!

Lucy’s verdict:

Entertainment – 4

Marketing success – 8

 

M&S Food

Product-focused, the quality and luxury of M&S Food are communicated well through this attempt. Celebrity endorsement helps to draw people in and attractive visuals leave our mouths watering!

Lucy’s verdict:

Entertainment – 5

Marketing success – 9

 

Morrisons

Morrisons have gone hard on the Christmas dinner with all the trimmings in their festive advert. Good, clear production; this one is straight forward with a ‘does what it says on the tin’ approach. Loving the lively music too!

Lucy’s verdict: 

Entertainment – 6

Marketing success – 8

 

And there we have it, a run-down of this year’s best and worst Christmas ads from the brands we all know and love. We’re wishing everyone a big Merry Christmas from Synergy and hope you have a great festive period. If you want to engage your people creatively in the new year, get in touch

Similar Articles

19 November 2020

HR: How to prepare for the next 100 days

Increase in consumer spending and relaxation of Covid-19 restrictions over the summer helped speed up…

READ MORE

8 October 2020

McCann Synergy bags two wins at the IoIC 2020 Awards!

We’re buzzing today at McCann Synergy as we bask in the glory of not one,…

READ MORE

22 September 2020

Get your copy of our exclusive whitepaper on employer branding

Our popular whitepaper, 'Finders Keepers: Find and Keep the Best People with your Employer Brand',…

READ MORE

8 September 2020

Events

COMING UP November 4th-6th: World Employer Branding Day World Employer branding Day returns for 2020. We'll be…

READ MORE
SEE MORE ARTICLES